March 22, 2015

Visions for TAFE future lost in dash to private profits

By John Kaye

The struggle for the future of public sector provision of vocational education and training is gearing up for its next big engagement, the NSW election on March 28.

Anecdotal reports suggest that soaring fees and non-functional software have crashed TAFE enrolments. Students with disability are being turned away because of a lack of support. Courses are not running and students and staff are struggling to keep the system viable.

As predicted the competitive market for state funding has taken an immediate and devastating toll on TAFE, with worse to come if it is not stopped, or at least, profoundly tamed.

At stake is not just how much of NSW's $2.3 billion annual VET budget ends up in the hands of training corporations, or even the affordability of education for working class Australians.

These are critical issues that had a determinative bearing on the outcome of the state elections in Queensland and Victoria and are likely to do so again in NSW.

However, even more significant to the future of the state and the nation will be the rebirth of the expectation of a quality public education for every Australian.

According to the NSW Auditor-General, in 2014/15 about 19 percent of the state's total vocational education and training budget was contestable, up from 11 percent the year before. That means that $439 million of public funds are at risk of ending up in the hands of private providers this financial year.

The state's Smart and Skilled training market is only in operation for the second half of 2014/15. All other things being equal, it can be anticipated that the contestable market will consume 27 percent of the training budget, or $624 million, in 2015/16.

Based on a University of Sydney Business School study, about 30 percent of public subsidies paid to corporate RTOs end up as raw profit.

Next year, the big training companies could claw out $190 million in profits from NSW taxpayers.

Smart and Skilled, like its evil siblings in other states, is an open invitation to the corporate sector to reap profits by cutting course hours, undermining teacher professionalism and exploiting students.

With the promise of a $190 million a year reward, the corporate sector is being invited into NSW to debase standards and squeeze down costs.

You can almost hear the claims of "mission accomplished" from the Dr Strangelove bureaucrats and politicians who have dedicated two decades of their best years to the task of turning education for working class Australians into a commodity.

However, another story is told by the voters' revolt against the governments in Queensland and Victoria that were left with the VET reform parcel when the music stopped and the damage to TAFE became obvious.

The Greens believe that this is the time for a new vision for TAFE. The first step is the complete restoration of funding, lost courses and course hours, deleted teaching and student support positions, and impaired equity functions.

The next step is to take back from the private sector not just the money but also the ability to set standards.

The task of restoring the rights of working people to a quality education is completed by dumping training packages and building instead the expectation that every member of the community will have a comprehensive understanding of their political, social, physical, cultural and intellectual environment.

The TAFE-driven election results in eastern Australia will be the beginning of making that future a reality.

New figures quantify the extent of the TAFE disaster

New figures quantify the extent of the TAFE disaster

In this piece Professor Wheelahan takes a closer look at how TAFEs are being funded, and the effects of underfunding.
The future of work and the future of skills

The future of work and the future of skills

Jim Stanford reflects on the transformation of the world of work and the importance of TAFE in a changing world.
Income contingent loans and justice: is the system fair?

Income contingent loans and justice: is the system fair?

There is a lot of discussion and debate aboutVET FEE-HELP and VET Student Loans. But are these income contingent loans fair?
Why vocational education matters now more than ever

Why vocational education matters now more than ever

Anne Jones looks at how we can design education to nurture the capabilities needed for an active and equitable citizenship in a digital society.
Get involved in National TAFE Day

Get involved in National TAFE Day

National TAFE Day is being held on Tuesday 19 June. Here are some ideas to get involved.
TAFE in Australia: beyond survival

TAFE in Australia: beyond survival

TAFE colleges and campuses across Australia have been significant key public education institutions for over four decades. The educational mission and breadth of the important work that TAFE does is unfortunately not well understood or recognised.
In defence of basket weaving

In defence of basket weaving

Senator Simon Birmingham's recent comments about basket weaving and TAFE have justifiably raised the ire of the Australian community.
Turning the ship around

Turning the ship around

This blog looks at the vocational education sector, reflecting on the worst of the scams and rorts; and the regulatory and policy agendas and poses the question - is it too late for the sector to change course?
Saving TAFE: what will it take?

Saving TAFE: what will it take?

TAFE is a shadow of its former self and it needs massive reinvestment if it is to recover from the systematic disinvestment by multiple governments over the last decade. What will it take to save TAFE?
Another step towards guaranteed funding for TAFE

Another step towards guaranteed funding for TAFE

The commitment of the South Australian Premier is another step towards guaranteed funding for TAFE.