March 22, 2015

Visions for TAFE future lost in dash to private profits

By John Kaye

The struggle for the future of public sector provision of vocational education and training is gearing up for its next big engagement, the NSW election on March 28.

Anecdotal reports suggest that soaring fees and non-functional software have crashed TAFE enrolments. Students with disability are being turned away because of a lack of support. Courses are not running and students and staff are struggling to keep the system viable.

As predicted the competitive market for state funding has taken an immediate and devastating toll on TAFE, with worse to come if it is not stopped, or at least, profoundly tamed.

At stake is not just how much of NSW's $2.3 billion annual VET budget ends up in the hands of training corporations, or even the affordability of education for working class Australians.

These are critical issues that had a determinative bearing on the outcome of the state elections in Queensland and Victoria and are likely to do so again in NSW.

However, even more significant to the future of the state and the nation will be the rebirth of the expectation of a quality public education for every Australian.

According to the NSW Auditor-General, in 2014/15 about 19 percent of the state's total vocational education and training budget was contestable, up from 11 percent the year before. That means that $439 million of public funds are at risk of ending up in the hands of private providers this financial year.

The state's Smart and Skilled training market is only in operation for the second half of 2014/15. All other things being equal, it can be anticipated that the contestable market will consume 27 percent of the training budget, or $624 million, in 2015/16.

Based on a University of Sydney Business School study, about 30 percent of public subsidies paid to corporate RTOs end up as raw profit.

Next year, the big training companies could claw out $190 million in profits from NSW taxpayers.

Smart and Skilled, like its evil siblings in other states, is an open invitation to the corporate sector to reap profits by cutting course hours, undermining teacher professionalism and exploiting students.

With the promise of a $190 million a year reward, the corporate sector is being invited into NSW to debase standards and squeeze down costs.

You can almost hear the claims of "mission accomplished" from the Dr Strangelove bureaucrats and politicians who have dedicated two decades of their best years to the task of turning education for working class Australians into a commodity.

However, another story is told by the voters' revolt against the governments in Queensland and Victoria that were left with the VET reform parcel when the music stopped and the damage to TAFE became obvious.

The Greens believe that this is the time for a new vision for TAFE. The first step is the complete restoration of funding, lost courses and course hours, deleted teaching and student support positions, and impaired equity functions.

The next step is to take back from the private sector not just the money but also the ability to set standards.

The task of restoring the rights of working people to a quality education is completed by dumping training packages and building instead the expectation that every member of the community will have a comprehensive understanding of their political, social, physical, cultural and intellectual environment.

The TAFE-driven election results in eastern Australia will be the beginning of making that future a reality.

A Sector with no Clothes

A Sector with no Clothes

A very different and humorous look at vocational education in Australia.
Increase funding to TAFE, not more student loans

Increase funding to TAFE, not more student loans

As the unfolding funding catastrophe in TAFE and vocational education was revealed again this week, it has elicited calls from those who have been at the forefront of the introduction of Income Contingent Loans into the sector to further expand them to lower level VET qualifications. As the magnitude of this disaster unfolds, it makes no sense that those at the forefront of the creation of a VET market espouse a further shift of funding responsibility for the sector onto individual students.
TAFE success at training awards

TAFE success at training awards

TAFE institutions, students and teachers dominated at the 2017 Australian Training Awards.
The rise and fall of Careers Australia

The rise and fall of Careers Australia

A brief examination of the meteoric rise of Careers Australia, and the implications for students, teachers and the vocational education sector.
New models: partnerships and innovation

New models: partnerships and innovation

Mary Faraone reflects on the future of TAFE and concludes that "the trick is to be ready for opportunities and develop a vision that respects and is loyal to the past but looks to the future."
Skilling Australians Fund

Skilling Australians Fund

Effective skills formation is essential to our national economic and social wellbeing. It will be the difference between whether as a nation we prosper or decline.
The Failure of For-Profit Education: Implications for TAFE

The Failure of For-Profit Education: Implications for TAFE

Among the many failures in the education ‘reform’ movement, the attempt to promote for-profit education has been the most complete. For-profit education has failed at every level.
Vouchers won't fix the TAFE system

Vouchers won't fix the TAFE system

Jennifer Westacott and the Business Council of Australia’s proposals for Education and Skills released at the National Press Club today are another disappointing suggestion that fails to recognise the very real issues facing vocational education in this country.
Does your MP support guaranteed funding for TAFE

Does your MP support guaranteed funding for TAFE

The TAFE sector is the lowest funded education sector and funding has declined by more than 24% since 2008. As privatization of the sector has increased, and as more and more government funding has gone to private for profit providers ...
Seismic changes in TAFE

Seismic changes in TAFE

In 2017 TAFE is at the brink of seismic change. Over the last five years intensified marketisation of the vocational education sector, the uncapping of undergraduate degree funding and the decline of TAFE-based vocational education programs for schools have brought TAFE institutions to the brink of insolvency and incapacity.